Golf Information

What Do Trees Have to Do With Golf?


On our way back from a recent round of golf, Fritz and I were discussing the way most golfers evaluate golf courses. We've had this discussion before, and it inevitably gets around to my heartfelt conviction that trees do not enhance the "golfing experience".

Most golfers in North America assume that golf is not golf without tree-lined fairways. If I am not mistaken, this is a bias created by a century of golf course design compliments of a relatively small number of trend-setting designers. In Canada, Stanley Thompson was the main man. His course designs can be found across the country, and inevitably they feature lush green (soft) fairways lined with majestic trees.

Of course there are many reasons for this, both practical and esthetic. For starters, eastern North America has lots of trees, and just as important, it is impossible to replicate the sandy turf of Scotland or Ireland in other parts of the world that do not share the same climate.

Nevertheless it struck me as a bit odd when on a recent trip to Saskatchewan we found the same type of fairways in that relatively dry prairie climate as we have here in our much more humid environment in southern Ontario.

What we have seen in first half of the last century was a progression from the use of native grasses in a place like St. Andrews or Dornoch, Scotland to the use of highly manipulated hybrids like bentgrass in Ontario, where the climate can (more or less) support them (with constant watering, of course).

But rather than using native grasses in the prairie or semi-desert settings of the North American western plain, course designers in those regions seem to have imported the ideas developed in the east. Especially the use of trees and non-native grasses.

One course we played near Elbow, Saskatchewan had water lying around from the overnight watering. This was in spite of the recent rainy period in the area. And while the greens seemed to be holding up well, they were typically left quite long and shaggy so they could withstand the inevitable dry spell that was just around the corner.

Seems to me there should be native grasses that would do better than this. Of course I could be completely wrong...

My point is that golf course design in North America has often created synthetic environments that alienate the golfer from the native terrain and turf. Which gets me back to trees...

To my way of thinking, that trees should come into play during a round of golf seems an unfortunate departure from the original way the game was conceived. Once you play a bit of links golf you realize that the game was originally meant to be played by running the ball along the ground. Like curling, that other Scottish obsession, the game represents an attempt to control the way the ball (stone) interacts with the course (ice).

In the first 100 years or so of golf in North America we have tried to take this element out of the game by making sure that the ground remains soft, that the grass is as green and lush as possible, and that there are as many strategically placed trees as possible to get in the way of our drives and approach shots.

On the other hand, trees are an important part of the native landscape in many parts of North America, so I would be contradicting myself if I said they should not be part of a "natural" layout in eastern North American. I am not advocating the "denuding" of the landscape in order to create a pseudo links-like environment. But trees should remain strictly in the background as far as I am concerned. Thankfully, this seems to be the way golf course design has been moving for the last 15 years or so.

From Golf Stories at Internetgolfreview.com

Visit the article section at Internetgolfreview.com for more golf stories, articles and golf travel features.

Rick Hendershot is a writer, avid golfer creator of the Linknet Publishing Network. For online advertising opportunities, visit Linknet advertising options.


MORE RESOURCES:

Zee News

'Tiger Woods' tops this season's golf games
International Herald Tribune, France - 7 hours ago
AP WASHINGTON: If you're like most sports fans, you haven't watched that much golf since June, when Tiger Woods won the US Open — and then announced he was ...
Hit the virtual green with new 'Tiger' golf game USA Today
This Week in Golf - September 4th through September 7th Sports Network
Rain washes out first round of BMW Championship The Associated Press
Independent and Free Press - Newsday
all 554 news articles


Sydney Morning Herald

Pro golf is having a bigger presence in the Bay Area
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - Sep 4, 2008
"Looking back, you could argue we should have been more involved earlier in Northern California golf, beyond Pebble Beach," he said in an interview last ...
Tommy Bolt Telegraph.co.uk
Starting Lines: Tommy Bolt Dies Hartford Courant
1958 US Open winner was known for temper Arizona Republic
United Press International - About - News & Issues
all 125 news articles


Preferred Golf Club(TM) Members Score Complimentary Round of Golf ...
MarketWatch - 10 hours ago
Launched just one year ago, Preferred Golf Club(TM), created by Preferred Hotel Group in conjunction with American Express(R) for its Cardmembers, ...


Callaway Golf President and CEO Signs New Agreement
MarketWatch - 9 hours ago
"The Board is very pleased that Mr. Fellows will continue to lead the Company," said Ronald S. Beard, Chairman of the Board, Callaway Golf Company. ...
President en CEO Callaway Golf tekent nieuwe overeenkomst Netherlands Corporate News (persbericht)
all 13 news articles


Kansas City Star

Im leads Canadian Tour Championship
Sports Network - 8 hours ago
... Daniel Im fired an eight-under 64 on Thursday to take the first-round lead of the season-ending Canadian Tour Championship at National Pines Golf Club. ...
Im leads Canadian Tour Championship by one stroke after first round The Canadian Press
Gustav leftovers push back BMW Championship tee time Ottawa Citizen
Branshaw grabs one-shot lead on a day of aces at the Utah Championship PGA.com
Deseret News - Seattle Post Intelligencer
all 548 news articles


The Money Times

LPGA Tour's English rule caught many in Korean community by ...
ESPN - Sep 3, 2008
"If these players don't take this step [and learn English]," she told Golf World, "their ability to earn a living is reduced. ...
A triple-bogey blunder Chicago Tribune
In Yer Face Winnipeg Sun
Critics need mulligan on LPGA policy USA Today
The Associated Press - KBS
all 513 news articles


Cook County forest preserve panel may buy member's golf course
Chicago Tribune, United States - 5 hours ago
By Hal Dardick | Chicago Tribune reporter The Cook County Forest Preserve Commission on Thursday launched negotiations to buy a golf course owned by one of ...
Cook Co. commissioner in bind over land Chicago Daily Herald
all 3 news articles


Golf: Old comrades beg to differ on Ryder Cup
WalesOnline, United Kingdom - 2 hours ago
Phil Price and Paul McGinley wrote their name into Belfry folklore helping Europe wrest golf’s most coveted prize off America in 2002 to where it remains ...
Azinger doesn't rule out Tiger attending Ryder Cup matches - Golf ESPN
Golf-Azinger will have open line to Tiger during Ryder Cup Reuters.uk
The 37th Ryder Cup CNN
Times Online - ESPN
all 1,138 news articles


Setanta Sports

Time to fix the playoffs and here's where to start - Golf
ESPN - 12 hours ago
"So you just need to go out and take care of your business." Bob Harig covers golf for ESPN.com. He can be reached at BobHarig@gmail.com.
Weir jumps to 24th spot in world golf rankings CBC.ca
New points system does not reward consistency Irish Times
Harrington wins Golfer of the Month for August European Tour
PGA Tour - Belfast Telegraph
all 96 news articles


GOLF TOM YANTZ
Hartford Courant, United States - Sep 4, 2008
I've noticed that almost every week on Tour now that the golf courses change so much from Thursday to Sunday that's it's almost like you're not playing the ...
Williamson knows that Bellerive will persevere St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Golf odds: BMW Championship WagerWeb
St. Louis native to play golf tourney on home course Belleville News Democrat
Golfbidder Limited - WorldGolf.com
all 49 news articles

Golf - Google News

home | site map
© 2006