Insurance Information

What Should I Do About Billing Problems When Using HSA Money?


If you run into a billing problem or misunderstanding with a hospital or doctor's office for which you're planning to use money from your Health Savings Account (HSA), you could be in trouble.

This article will help you understand how hospital and doctor visits are different when paying with a Health Savings Account. Not better or worse, just different.

If you have an HSA, you must have health insurance. It's a requirement. However, if you are using money from your HSA, it means that you haven't hit the deductible of your policy yet.

In this particular situation, life is a bit different when it comes to resolving billing disputes with hospitals.

Insurance companies have a comprehensive system for dealing with billing disputes when they have covered a hospital stay or doctor visit. But when they haven't covered it because you are still within your deductible, that comprehensive dispute resolution system doesn't necessarily apply.

Here are some points to keep in mind when you are dealing with a hospital in a billing dispute, and you have paid with HSA money. I learned these important points when I was talking to an expert in this field named Dr. Vincent Riccardi, who is the owner of American Medical Consumer (www.medconsumer.com), a company dedicated to helping people resolve billing disputes with hospitals and doctors.

Here's what Dr. Riccardi has to say:

  • First, discuss the issue with your physician. Sometimes the problem stems from an incorrectly applied billing code and the doctor can easily change it to please the hospital and resolve the problem on the spot.
  • Negotiate in person. Especially if you just don't have the money to pay a bill, it makes the best sense to negotiate face-to-face with the person at the hospital who has the authority to reverse or reduce the charges. Hospitals would often rather be paid part of a bill than risk losing the entire bill. Be honest and forthright and you may have a good chance in negotiating a reduced fee from the hospital. This includes the situations where it was a misunderstanding on your part. It's at least worth a try.
  • Don't bother going to the State Medical Board. In most cases, they are not able to help you. This is the case with most government agencies. Even the Departments of Insurance cannot help, because this isn't an insurance problem, it is technically a fee-for-service situation.
  • Recourse to a lawyer is usually not fruitful unless there is a big amount involved. For amounts less than $5,000 (which is what most HSA-style deductibles are), a lawyer probably won't be able to help you.
  • Remember that the only things that count in negotiations like this are the things that have been written down. If a doctor mentioned something to you but didn't write it down, it probably won't help you. Get things in writing all the way through the process.
  • I think of HSAs as a way to "be your own insurance company" for the small stuff (under your deductible). That is its power. But it also means that when it comes to disputes, you also have to "be your own insurance company" and take charge of the negotiations with the hospital, just like an insurance company would. Your willingness and ability to negotiate will influence your ability to get unfair charges reversed or, at least, lessened. But it's a "do it yourself" situation, so be aware of that when you sign up for an HSA.

    Daryl Kulak is the author of the book "Health Insurance Off the Grid - A Wonderful Way to Use Alternative Medicine and Save Money on Insurance Using the New Health Savings Account (HSA)."

    The book provides a nine-step plan to get your self-employed or small business health insurance costs under control using a unique approach you won't find anywhere else. The book is available for sale as an e-Book or paperback at the Website http://www.healthoffthegrid.com


    MORE RESOURCES:

    Boston Globe

    Voters want solutions as health insurance costs rise sharply
    Kansas City Star, MO - Oct 11, 2008
    By SUZANNE KING Dave Coffman of Lee’s Summit has been working two part-time jobs since he retired so he can afford long-term care insurance, ...
    Video: McCain, Obama Differ Dramatically on Health Care AssociatedPress
    Candidates' health plans compared Philadelphia Daily News
    Health care: Curing what ails us St. Charles Sun
    UW Badger Herald - Los Angeles Times
    all 894 news articles


    Natural News.com

    Learning the hard way about FDIC insurance
    San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - Oct 11, 2008
    That experience motivated Quittel to mount a campaign urging the FDIC to require banks to warn depositors if their account balance is over the insurance ...
    Elder Law: Pay attention to FDIC insurance rules The News-Press
    FDIC approves $250000 insurance limit International Herald Tribune
    Bank Failures Sit at Unlucky 13, But Maybe Not For Long TIME
    The Citizen.com - Tampa Tribune
    all 621 news articles


    Australia Senate to support health insurance changes
    Reuters - 5 hours ago
    The private health insurance industry has warned the government plans would lead to 400000 people dropping their private health cover. ...


    Variable-Annuity Business Is Adding to Life Insurers' Woes
    Wall Street Journal - 4 hours ago
    By LAVONNE KUYKENDALL Variable annuities, whose sales fueled profits at life-insurance companies in recent years, are starting to drag profits as the stock ...
    Despite the Turmoil, Insurance Companies Appear Safe TIME
    Market Place Insurance Industry Joins Banking Giants on the Hot Seat New York Times
    Consider Staking a Claim in Allstate Barron's
    Forbes - CNNMoney.com
    all 51 news articles


    Ahead on health insurance
    The Star-Ledger - NJ.com, NJ - 6 hours ago
    Both presidential candidates have promised health insurance action on the national level. Given the way Washington works, it is not likely that any ...
    Report: Ind. workers losing job-provided coverage Chicago Tribune
    Fewer Americans get health cover through employers Business Insurance
    Health-care system needs new thinking, rules and initiatives Akron Beacon Journal
    all 19 news articles


    Popular autism treatment often goes uncovered
    Seattle Post Intelligencer - 11 hours ago
    None of it is covered by the family's health insurance plan. Insurance industry representatives such as Susan Pisano, spokeswoman for the national industry ...


    Insurance Fraud Bureau of Massachusetts to Cut Hours from ...
    PR Web (press release), WA - 1 hour ago
    Customer Expressions, the creators of the i-Sight Investigative Software, announced today that the Insurance Fraud Bureau of Massachusetts has implemented ...


    The Associated Press

    Legislation levels the insurance field for physical or mental ...
    The Free Lance-Star, VA - Oct 11, 2008
    FOR THOSE WHO suffer from a mental illness, and those who love them, the question has long been this: Why does the guy next door with diabetes get ...
    Sen. Pete Domenici on Mental Health TIME
    Law Equalizes Coverage For Mental, Physical Care Washington Post
    Mental Health Coverage New York Times
    Kansas City Star - The Herald-Times (subscription)
    all 186 news articles


    ABC News

    Fidelity, Vanguard join money-fund insurance plan
    Seattle Times, United States - Oct 12, 2008
    Fidelity Investments have joined the US Treasury's emergency insurance program for money-market mutual funds, pushing the participation rate to more than 95 ...
    Low-risk investments can offer safety to investors Poughkeepsie Journal
    Funds Turn To Treasury Guaranty Washington Post
    Money Market Mutual Funds Apply for Treasury's Insurance Program On Wall Street
    The State - Wall Street Journal
    all 285 news articles


    Washington Post

    EDITORIAL: Stock markets on ropes
    Asahi Shimbun, Japan - 7 hours ago
    Adding to this unpleasant economic news, Yamato Life Insurance Co., a midsize firm that invested heavily in REIT and other high-risk US financial ...
    Japan's Yamato Life Insurance files for bankruptcy Hindu
    Japanese insurance co Yamoto collapses; files for bankruptcy Hindu Business Line
    Japan in desperate effort to halt its own downward economic spiral Telegraph.co.uk
    Financial Times - The Daily Yomiuri
    all 437 news articles

    Insurance - Google News

    home | site map
    © 2006