PR Information

Media Training: When Reporters Bully You


UNDER FIRE

A friend whose organization is often in the media spotlight recently told me a story about her boss. Her boss, let's call her Susan, is on the leadership team for a lobbying group that represents a somewhat unpopular industry.

Susan was interviewed a few months ago by Dateline NBC Correspondent Lea Thompson about a topic that could make her organization look bad. She knew she'd have to answer tough questions.

Nervous about saying something embarrassing about her organization, Susan carefully prepared for the interview. She developed her main messages, thought about the worst questions she could possibly face and practiced her responses.

When the interview began, Susan stayed on message. Thompson tried to throw her off, but Susan wouldn't budge. Thompson pushed and prodded, trying to get Susan to say something - anything - more controversial. She wouldn't.

That's when Ms. Thompson employed the old journalistic trick of trying to intimidate her subject. In middle of the interview, Ms. Thompson asked the cameraman to stop recording, scolded Susan for not answering her questions, and asked for a five minute break.

And my sources tell me that this is not the first time Ms. Thompson has used this tactic - she's used it before with at least one other interviewee from a different organization.

An inexperienced spokesperson would have been flustered. He or she would have returned from the break with something different to say. Not Susan. She knew that Dateline NBC was simply a conduit to a larger audience and that she had full control of her own words.

It worked. When the interview aired, Susan's quotes were right on message. By sticking to her messages and consistently repeating her most important points, she ensured that Dateline's millions of viewers heard the most important things she had to say.

WHY CAN'T I BE MORE?REAL?

The trainees I work with often wonder if they wouldn't have more credibility if they acknowledged a few of their own weaknesses during an interview, instead of being perfectly on message. Doing so is occasionally appropriate, but here's why it's dangerous:

1. The answer you give which points out your own shortcomings will be the one that is used. Your other answers - including your positive points - will be edited out.

2. It is not your job to be your own critic - that is the job of the reporter and your opponents quoted in the piece. In order for a truly "balanced" piece, you have to be positive toward yourself - your opponents will happily point out your imperfections for you.

BUT BE CAREFUL

I'd like to raise three cautions with this approach. First, frustrated reporters will occasionally edit together clips of the guest repeating the same answer over and over again and will air it to show the guest's evasiveness. It's a technique that can severely damage a guest's credibility, but is easy to circumvent - if you develop multiple ways of saying the same thing and support your messages with specific examples.

Second, this approach works well if you're defending an ideology or point of view you truly believe in. But if you or your organization did something wrong, it's not good enough. You'll need to admit your faults, apologize, and articulate your action plan to make it better.

And third, this approach worked because the interview was taped, not live. If the program was live, the audience would have quickly tired of Susan's antics. But since she knew that Dateline NBC tends to use short sound bites instead of longer interviews, she was confident the audience would never see her repetitive messaging technique.

THE END GAME

In the end, both women performed their jobs admirably. Ms. Thompson led a tough journalistic investigation, exposing an industry that probably deserved the scrutiny. And, as for Susan? She represented her organization's point of view perfectly.

Brad Phillips is the founder and president of Phillips Media Relations. He was formerly a journalist for ABC News and CNN, and headed the media relations department for the second largest environmental group in the world.

For more information and to sign up for free monthly media relations and media training e-tips, visit http://www.PhillipsMediaRelations.com


MORE RESOURCES:

Truancy Endangers Graduation Goal in Pr. George's
Washington Post, United States - 5 hours ago
By Nelson Hernandez The Prince George's County Board of Education recognized a grim reality last night in the struggle to get more than 2700 high school ...


Weather Causes Multiple Fires at Pr. George's Building
Washington Post, United States - Dec 1, 2008
AP Prince George's County fire officials said high winds and a rain gutter have caused multiple fires at an apartment complex. County fire spokesman Mark ...


New York Daily News

Ford's PR campaign: CEO Alan Mulally drives to hearings (no ...
New York Daily News, NY - 7 hours ago
BY CATEY HILL In a massive about-face for Ford, CEO Alan Mulally drives - as in, no private jet - to the bailout hearings and says he'll accept a $1 yearly ...


How to Use Social Networking Sites for Marketing and PR
New York Times, United States - 2 hours ago
Krista Canfield, LinkedIn's public relations manager, suggests you treat your contacts like you treat your Rolodex. "You wouldn't hand over your Rolodex to ...


US judge tosses some charges against PR governor
Forbes, NY - 9 hours ago
By MIKE MELIA , 12.02.08, 09:03 AM EST A US judge has thrown out most of the federal corruption charges against Puerto Rico's governor, who faces trial in ...


Attorney: most charges against PR governor tossed
International Herald Tribune, France - Dec 1, 2008
AP SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico: The attorney for Puerto Rico's governor says a federal judge has thrown out most of the federal corruption charges against his ...


ABC News

Big Three CEOs Stage PR Comeback?
Minyanville.com, New York - 6 hours ago
The 40-watt lightbulb deep in the heads of Detroit's CEOs flickered to life as they attempted to stage one of the biggest public relations comebacks in the ...
GM & Ford Bow To Pressure, Will Sell Corporate Jet Fleets Aero-News Network
all 12 news articles


Managing PR Crises
Chronicle of Higher Education (subscription) - 16 hours ago
by topic | by date | by column By RUSSELL POWELL While experience may be the best teacher, it's not something most public-relations officers covet when it ...


JHG Selected as PR Agency of Record for National University System
Business Wire (press release), CA - 10 hours ago
JHG’s public relations division has been the agency of record for National University, an affiliate to the System, since 2004. JHG approaches this new role ...


PR Newswire High Technology Summary, Monday, Dec. 1, 2008
MarketWatch - Dec 1, 2008
Dec 01, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Following is a summary of technology news releases transmitted today by PR Newswire. The full text of these releases ...
PR Newswire Summary of EntertaiNet Copy, Monday, Dec. 1, 2008 MarketWatch
all 11 news articles

PR - Google News

home | site map
© 2006